Recipe – The Ultimate Butter Cookies (some say, it tastes like Jenny Bakery!)
When Jenny Bakery arrived in Singapore, everyone went crazy. We see queues forming early in the morning despite the heat and haze outside. This Hong Kong’s cookie shop is famous for its butter and coffee cookies which draw long queues in Hong Kong and are so popular that a black market has sprung up with resellers offering the cookies at rocket high prices.
I got a little crazy over it too. Because it’s almost impossible to get the cookies in Hong Kong nor in Singapore (unless you queue for hours). So I went online to google for butter cookies recipe, hoping to bake some for my own consumption. Shockingly, I found that many avid bakers have been coming up with recipes that tastes VERY SIMILAR to Jenny’s biscuits!
In my house, we experimented with three different recipes and conducted a blind test in the family. The first recipe, we used 125g butter, 55g caster sugar, 32ml milk, 126g cake flour and 60g rice flour. It turned out hard and we had to dip it into our drinks to soften it. The second recipe, we used 200g butter, 50g caster sugar, 75g all-purpose flour, 75g bread flour and 50g corn starch. It was not bad, a little bit of bite but didn’t exactly melt in the mouth. The third time, we substituted all-purpose flour to top flour (wheat flour) and it was softer but I think can be better.
After experimenting it again last night fine tuning the recipe, we are very happy. When you placed our butter cookies in the mouth, IT MELTS LITERALLY. Like you don’t even have to bite it. And the use of Golden Churn Tin Butter brings so much fragrance to the cookies. Let me remind you to sift the flour because it is much lighter than unsifted flour and aerates it at the same time, hence making the cookies airy and delicate. I really love it and we already have plans to bake more of it and give it as Christmas presents for our friends!
Presenting to you…. THE ULTIMATE BUTTER COOKIES!
- 200g butter
- 50g icing sugar, sifted
- 50g plain flour
- 100g wheat flour (or top flour)
- 50g corn flour
- Preheat oven to 180 degree celsius.
- Cream butter and gradually add in the sifted icing sugar and beat till pale and fluffy.
- Sift plain flour, wheat flour and corn flour twice.
- Fold the ingredients together with a spatula until it is well incorporated. Do not beat or over mix as you will not achieve the airy texture.
- Put the dough into a piping bag with star dip nozzle.
- Pipe the cookies onto the baking tray lined with baking paper. Leave 1 cm in between cookies as they will expand a little during baking.
- Bake for 15-20 minutes or until the cookies turn light golden brown.
- Leave it to cool on a cooling rack before storing them in air-tight container.
- MUST USE Golden Churn Tin Butter
i haven’t try jenny’s bakery cookies, but i would love to try the recipe that u recommend… ^^
Great recipie! Could you share where you bought the Golden Churn tin butter? Will try this out as soon as I get my hands on it!
NTUC 🙂
May I know what is wheat flour?
Is it the same as cake flour?
Yes i think it is similar. it is soft wheat flour.
Great to see tgis recipe! Thanks. You mentioned corn starch, meaning i need to get a starch? Add in at which stage? Or do you mean corn flour?
Sorry, I mean corn flour.
Hey babe, is all purpose flour plain flour?
|
can!
Hai my friend give me yr recepi. I had try for this deepavali and its turn out very well . Thanks
Hope you will try to unravel the secrets of the coffee cookies next!
Hi where do you get the Golden Churn Butter. Went phoon Huat can’t find. Went cold storage and couldn’t find at the aisle either. Am I searching in wrong direction?
NTUC 🙂
You can get it from NTUC extra. I got mine from Jem-Jurong East
Thank you and I had done 3 times with the 3rd receipe. Indeed it melted in mouth. I used Australian salted butter block but found it too buttery. Will try golden churn . Thanks again.
Try not to use salted butter when it comes to baking(anything). Always use unsalted butter:)
Hi did u all tried this recipe works with salted or non salted butter?
Have you tried making the coffee ones? Would you suggest just adding coffee powder? Do share if you’ve tried them. Thanks!
trying it this weekend!
Have you tried the coffee cookies?
How much coffee powder I should add?
2 tbsp!
Hi from the pics, you beat up the ingredients together while your step 4 proposed to fold it Which can achieve a more desirable result?
Ah! thanks for pointing that out. actually, i fold the flour into the mixture as written in the recipe. the one that was added to the butter was icing sugar. 🙂
Hello! May I know how do you store the leftover and opened tin butter? Will the butter be affected if I put it into the fridge and use it next time? 🙂
i put it in the fridge as well. of course, i soften it first before using it.
I just tried your recipe and it turned out so good !
Basic ingredients, simple steps, fuss free and quick turn around time ! – definitely a recipe worth keeping!
– but of course the most important thing is cookies did taste very good ! Not too sweet, flavourful, crispy on the outside and melts in the mouth !
Excellent and THANK YOU!
If I don’t use a piping but cookies cutter, will it affect the texture when baking?
it’s quite soft, think it will be quite difficult to use a cookie cutter.
My colleague gave me the recipe. Cookies turned out to be “yummy”. Wl try again putting walnut or almond next time. Thank you for sharing.
Tried this recipe with an added pinch of salt. Result was a fragrant cookie with a soft and crumbly texture that tasted very similar to those of Jenny’s Bakery. Thank you for a great recipe! 🙂
Hi there, wanna ask wads the difference btw the tin butter compared to the ones in the chiller?
tin butter can be used imeediately. the ones in the chiller needs to be softened.
Tried the receipe. The taste was great. But while baking, I noticed the cookie spread out and the shape flattened. Wondering what’s the cause of it.
Could be due to over mixing. For the last step, was told to fold in the flour gently to avoid over mixing.
The cookies taste great! But I have the same problem… The cookies spread a lot and flattened while baking… Wonder why why why?
Hi Thanks for sharing the recipe. I tried but my cookie spread out and flatten too. What did I do wrongly?
Can advise please? Thanks.
Hi u stated 50g icing sugar is it sweet enough??
As I tried jenny cookies n is pretty sweet
So I just wonder is it sweet enough
Thks
i don’t really take too sweet. so i dropped the sugar level. u can go for 80g or 100g if u like 🙂
hi. any difference if use normal caster sugar instead of icing sugar?
It effects texture. Icing sugar contains a little corn starch which will make the cookies more tender and “sandy”.
Hi, may I know how many cookies you made with that size based on the recipe?
can make about 60-70
Hi thanks for sharing the recipe!
I tried and the recipe yields only abt 30 cookies:(
I used 1cm for piping.. Hmm did I missed something?
Me too…mine even worse, I can only make 25 cookies
Tried the recipe today and it turns out really well. The cookies kept it shape and taste very good and buttery! Great recipe!
Hi,
The corn four is the same as corn starch or you mean the yellow one?
yes corn starch!
Hi, would like to try out your receipe. how many cookies can I make from the above cookies? as i will need about 120 cookies
This recipe makes about 60-70. So u need to double it up! 🙂
May checking how many cookies does this recipe make?
about 60-70
I tried to make the cookies and they taste FANTASTIC (like the real deal)! May I know how long can the cookies last in room temperature environment?
3 days! cuz no preservatives!
I guess im pushing my luck because I just ate it.. and it’s been close to a week 😡
My cookies also spread out & flattened. How I can keep piped shape?
What’s the size of the tip that u used?
Texture is very good but really not sweet enough so I dusted icing sugar on top.
My cookies keep collapsing. I chilled in the fridge around 15 min but it still doesn’t help. Any comments?
Btw does the tin come with unsalted version? I just realized mine got salt
the tin version is the salted one, the unsalted one is the paper wrapped butter
This recipe is such a keeper! Loved the results, though I would add a little bit more sugar the next time. It yielded 30 cookies.. maybe i made them too big. Thank you for sharing!!
You mentioned 2 tbsp coffee powder for coffee flavour. Is it instant coffee powder? Will let u know how mine turned out, thank you for your post!
I love this recipe! Thank you for sharing.
Hi Maureen. Thanks for sharing. I tried your recipe n the cookies were really good though it’s my first try. I used salted president butter n it’s a little salty. Next try I will use golden churn. Do u use salted or unsalted? Thanks.
Good to hear that, June!
I tried the recipe but mine didn’t turn out fluffy enough. It seems a little dry and flat. Not like yours. Can you tell me why?
Hello, i dont have the golden churn butter. Can i use salted butter block instead? Thanks.
Can but not as fragrant 🙂
Hi Maureen, u r such a generous sweetie, tks for being so humble. Have a great day.
hi Maureen i did a batch but they turned out a little too salty, how may i fix this
Use unsalted butter 🙂
im using golden churn canned butted which is what is called for, there is no canned unsalted version butter available unless u mean the typical chilled block of unsalted butter instead of canned butter.
Help me out please, the recipe is really good gonna do it again
done twice is there a great way to do piping of the cookies mine always melts into a lump taste good though
Hi, i chance upon ur recipe n tried it jus now. Taste was really good
CaN I use cake flour instead of top flour?
can!
I tried the recipe, it turn out fine. But the butter is a little salty as it is salted butter. need to get unsalted butter. The sweetness also need to be increase a little, as it overpower by the salted butter. I will do a few batches with different sweetness level to try out.
Hi…Thks for sharing..look very nice!
Hi Maureen, many thanks for sharing. Please could you tell me what brand of corn flour you use? Is it the Brown & Polson Corn Flour in the brown and orange/yellow tin? There’s a lot of confusion on the Internet about whether to use corn starch or corn flour because different countries call it differently. Many thanks!
No eggs needed? Cool!
Tried your recipe and it was really good! My kids love them! Very close to Jenny’s. Thank you for sharing!
This was a very nice recipe, too sinful! However my cookies didn’t hold their shapes well 🙁 tasted good anyway!
Hi Maureen, just baked the cookies yesterday. So good. I followed the recipe to the T. It is perfect. I use the tin golden churn. Whipped it in the stand mixer wit the icing sugar n switch to fold it by hand. It was easy to pipe and came out great. I baked it for 10 minutes for the best colour. Thanks Maureen
Hi Maureen, tried this recipe and it taste really good. My first trial in baking butter cookies & it’s a success! Thanks for sharing. 🙂